Ex-FIA president encourages Massa to take back Hamilton’s title – In a recent development that reopens one of Formula One’s most controversial chapters, Brazilian driver Felipe Massa has received a significant boost in his bid to overturn the results of the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix.
Former FIA President Jean Todt has come out in support of Massa, acknowledging the unique nature of the infamous ‘Crashgate’ scandal. Such a move, if successful, would effectively strip Lewis Hamilton’s first drivers F1 title.

Verstappen puts his foot down over Marko departure
The unfolding of Crashgate
The 2008 Formula One season is often remembered for its dramatic finish and intense championship battle. But it’s also notorious for one of the sport’s most scandalous episodes, infamously known as ‘Crashgate’, during the Singapore Grand Prix.
The 2008 Singapore Grand Prix was a historic one for Formula 1, marking the series’ first ever night race. The glittering lights of the Marina Bay Street Circuit set the scene for what was expected to be a straightforward race. Behind the scenes, however, a conspiracy was brewing within the Renault team that would go on to shake the very foundations of the sport.
Renault, struggling with performance problems and desperate for a win, hatched a plan to have their driver, Nelson Piquet Jr, deliberately crash his car to bring out the safety car. The strategy was to benefit his team-mate Fernando Alonso, who had pitted early and would gain a significant advantage from the safety car period.
Wolff ‘outrage’ in German press: “FIA crossed a red line”
The execution and immediate aftermath
On lap 14, Piquet Jr. crashed at Turn 17, bringing out the safety car as planned. Alonso, who had pitted earlier, moved up the order as other drivers pitted under the safety car, ultimately leading to his victory. At the time, the crash was dismissed as a simple driver error and Renault celebrated a seemingly fluke victory.
FIA plans could see F1 cars 5 seconds slower
The revelation and the fallout
The true nature of the incident came to light in the second half of 2009, when Piquet Jr. and his father revealed that the crash had been deliberate. This confession led to an FIA investigation, which uncovered radio communications and evidence implicating team principal Flavio Briatore and chief technical officer Pat Symonds in orchestrating the crash.
Horner points out Perez huge weakness
Punishments and repercussions
The FIA’s World Motor Sport Council held a hearing into the matter, which resulted in severe consequences for those involved. Briatore was given an indefinite ban from FIA-sanctioned events (later overturned by a French court), while Symonds received a five-year suspension. Renault, as constructors, were given a suspended disqualification, essentially a probationary period. Piquet Jr, who had become a whistleblower, was not punished, but his F1 career was effectively over.
Crashgate raised significant ethical issues within Formula One. Deliberately crashing a car to gain a strategic advantage not only compromised the integrity of the sport, but also the safety of drivers, marshals and spectators. It was a stark reminder of the lengths to which teams will go to gain a competitive advantage.
Massa argues that had this crash not occurred, he would likely have maintained his position during the Grand Prix and not been forced to pit early, losing many places due to an accident with the refuelling hose still attached to his Ferrari upon exiting the pits.
Hamilton sidelined as F1 boss names top 3 drivers
Jean Todt’s take on the scandal
In an interview with L’Equipe, Todt highlighted the exceptional nature of Crashgate, where the fraud only came to light long after the race results had been confirmed.
“This case is special. There was proven fraud and we only found out about it later,” said Todt, referring to the FIA’s standard practice of finalising results by 31 December of each racing year.
“The FIA’s rule has always been that the results must be confirmed by December 31 and we never withdraw them. In the case of Singapore, the facts were only revealed a year later and the sanctions imposed by the FIA before my arrival were overturned by the Paris court.”
Massa’s quest for justice is based on the belief that the fraud had a significant impact on the outcome of the 2008 World Championship. If the race results had been annulled, it’s conceivable that Massa, rather than Hamilton, would have been crowned world champion.
The Brazilian has launched legal proceedings to explore the possibility of overturning the championship results.
Mercedes propose ‘bans’ for 2024
Ecclestone’s revelations and Todt’s regrets
Recent comments by former F1 boss Bernie Ecclestone have added a new dimension to the controversy. Ecclestone claimed that Max Mosley and Charlie Whiting, the then FIA president and race director, were aware of the plot from the start.
Todt, who succeeded Mosley as FIA president, expressed regret at the way the situation had been handled.
“According to Bernie Ecclestone, Max Mosley, my predecessor, and Charlie Whiting, race director, knew about it from the start. When I was president of the FIA, I was not informed about it,” he says.
“If it is confirmed that the association knew the truth before December 31, that could actually change things.”
“Unfortunately, Charlie and Max passed away. In hindsight, we should have requested that the race be canceled. The completely new fact, if true and verifiable, is that the regulatory body that declared the championship official knew about everything.”
‘Trophygate’: Hamilton v Fan claims
The legal hurdle and Todt’s hopes for justice
Despite Massa’s efforts and Todt’s support, the challenge lies in the FIA’s regulations, which state that race results are irreversible after the end of the racing year. However, Todt remains hopeful that justice will prevail for Massa, especially in light of Ecclestone’s revelations that FIA officials had prior knowledge of the incident.
The Crashgate scandal remains a contentious issue in the history of Formula One. Massa’s quest for justice, backed by Jean Todt’s support, underlines the ongoing debate about fairness and integrity in the sport. As the saga unfolds, the Formula One community is watching closely, anticipating the potential impact on one of the sport’s most dramatic championships.
MORE NEWS: Jean Todt joins the F1 criticism of FIA president
MORE F1 NEWS: How to watch new Schumacher documentary in UK
In a heartfelt tribute to one of Formula One’s most iconic figures, Lewis Hamilton has expressed his deep admiration for Michael Schumacher in the new German documentary series ‘Being Michael Schumacher’.
The documentary, which is airing exclusively in Germany, delves into the…READ MORE ON THIS STORY
With over 30 years of experience in Formula 1 as an insider journalist, I have built trusted connections across the paddock, from race engineers and mechanics to senior team figures. At The Judge 13, I and a handful of trusted colleagues share exclusive Formula 1 news, expert analysis and behind-the-scenes stories you will not find in mainstream motorsport media.
