When Cadillac announced yesterday that they were retaining the services of Valtteri Bottas in preference over F1 rookie Colton Herta, most paddock folk were in a state of shock. Before the name changed to Cadillac, the new application for the 11th team spot on the grid was under the name of Andretti.
Both Mario Andretti and his son Michael had promised the new team would have an all-American feel about it and an all-American driver. Yet understandably, in year one of setting up an F1 team from scratch, the team would want experienced drivers to give them all the feedback they can.
Herta’s Steep Learning Curve
So Colton Herta was plucked from the Andretti IndyCar team and sent to Europe to compete in Formula 2 in order to acquire the additional points to reach the FIA’s standard of 40. Herta and his Hitech team have not fared well this season,scoring no super licence points.
Cadillac then scheduled extra FP1 sessions for the Californian, each one worth a point so long as Herta completed 100km.He finally qualified for his final point in Sao Paulo FP1. Now ready to race in the world of F1, everyone expected Cadillac to ditch Bottas, given they had announced Sergio Perez has a new multi-year deal before the Mexican Grand Prix.
Bottas Stays Put
But no. Valtteri is here to stay – at least for now. Appearing at the FIA official press conference in Las Vegas, Bottas shrugged off the surprise questions, claiming Cadillac were sticking to a plan they already had.
“With Colton, it was always the plan this year that the team is trying to get enough points for him to get the super licence because if he misses it this year, it’s going to be almost impossible to get in the future. And it doesn’t mean that you need to use him immediately. There are several years that it will stay valid, so that was always the plan, so that’s all good.
“There’s been a bit too much noise in the last weeks. It’s been really unnecessary. But that’s why we wanted to put out official confirmation today, which I’ve known for a while that should be the case, so at least we can get rid of the noise,” Bottas concluded.
Development Realities and Setbacks
Yet did Herta believe when he agreed to leave Andretti IndyCar, that he would drop down a level in single-seater racing in F2, then sit around in the garage for a season waiting for his chance? The Californian is in his racing prime, and should be doing exactly that rather than being a reserve driver.
It was around the time Cadillac sacked their team principal, Graham Lowdon, that the rumours first emerged over Bottas’ impending doom. Further, there must have been some concerns within the team, given Sergio Perez has beaten his Cadillac teammate hands down.
And it may be the case Cadillac vastly overestimated where they would be come the last triple header of the 2026 season,so with whoever is driving, P21/P22 looks likely. It may be they feel the car is too far away from where they wanted it to be for Colton Herta, and so it needs more development and Bottas is the better of the two for that purpose.
That said, Herta hasn’t been tearing down any walls with his driving this season, but as Ollie Bearman and Kimi Antonelli have proven, F2 can go badly, but if an F1 team believes in you, that’s what matters.
A Rare Grid Continuity
Presuming Rafael Câmara remains the driver for Abu Dhabi with Haas F1, Cadillac’s retention of Bottas has caused a rare occurrence seen just once in F1 history. The drivers who finish in Abu Dhabi will be the same as the grid which forms up for the season opener in 2027. The only other time this occurred was between 2023/24 when Nyck de Vries was replaced by Daniel Ricciardo.
We’ve heard nothing from Colton Herta since the announcement, although his expectations will have been managed over the past weeks and days. As part of their driver announcement, Cadillac also confirmed that test and reserve drivers will be revealed in due course.
However, paddock veteran Chris Medland has reported that “it’s my understanding that Herta has so far declined a reserve role.” There are few options back in IndyCar for next year, given all the big team seats are confirmed. Minnow Dale Coyne Racing has one driver left to confirm.
Back in September, Herta also confirmed he had “no interest” in returning to F2 for another season. So for now the door is closed for the young Californian who must be irritated that his path to F1 has more obstacles in the way.
If Colton Herta has indeed declined the test and reserve driver role at Cadillac, it would be expected that behind-the-scenes relationships have broken down. And while the selection by Cadillac of Bottas is a little boring, then again it’s what Cadillac needs to get on top of their issues.
Would you like to see more TJ13 Formula 1 coverage? Add us to your favourites list on Google to receive trusted F1 news.
A.J. Hunt is Senior Editor at TJ13, where Andrew oversees editorial standards and contributes to the site’s Formula 1 coverage. A career journalist with experience in both print and digital sports media, Andrew trained in investigative journalism and has written for a range of European sports outlets.
At TJ13, Andrew plays a central role in shaping the site’s output, working across breaking news, analysis, and long-form features. Andrew’s responsibilities include fact-checking, refining editorial structure, and ensuring consistency in reporting across a fast-moving news cycle.
Andrew’s work focuses particularly on the intersection of Formula 1 politics, regulation, and team strategy. Andrew closely follows developments involving the FIA, team leadership, and driver market dynamics, helping to provide context behind the sport’s biggest stories.
With experience covering multiple seasons of Formula 1’s modern hybrid era, Andrew has developed a detailed understanding of how regulatory changes and competitive shifts influence the grid. Andrew’s editorial approach prioritises clarity and context, aiming to help readers navigate complex developments within the sport.
In addition to editorial duties, Andrew is particularly interested in how media narratives shape fan perception of Formula 1, and how reporting can balance speed with accuracy in an increasingly digital news environment.