#F1 History: 1969 – High Wings Banned

Brought to you by TheJudge13 chronicler Jennie Mowbray

Turn, turn, my wheel!  All things must change
To something new, to something strange;
  Nothing that is can pause or stay;
The moon will wax, the moon will wane,
The mist and cloud will turn to rain,
The rain to mist and cloud again,
To-morrow be to-day.

 ~Henry Wadsworth Longfellow~

The 1968 Formula One season had ended with the new rear wings continuing to evolve dramatically in elevation and dimensions at each succeeding race.  After their introduction by Lotus at the Monaco Grand Prix the new technology had spread through the whole paddock like a bush-fire.  However, it wasn’t all plain sailing, with 1969 continuing to be a year of ongoing innovation which, eventually, was restrained by further fine-tuning of the regulations.

South African Grand Prix

The first Grand Prix of 1969 was held on March 1st at Kyalami in South Africa.  The cars were now starting to look like a new breed of exotic bird with their varied display of the new spidery rear wings which were also spreading to the front of many of the cars.

There were a number of failures of the new devices during practice and during the race Jack Brabham, who had been on pole, suffered a rear wing collapse while he was in second place and was forced to pit for repairs. He ended up retiring on lap 32 because of suspension problems with his car, most likely caused by his wing collapse. Jackie Stewart in his Matra had passed Brabham at the end of the first lap and proceeded to maintain the lead the all the way to the finish line where he finished eighteen seconds ahead of Graham Hill.

Jackie Stewart in his Matra Cosworth MS10 at the South African GP

Jackie Stewart in his Matra Cosworth MS10 at the South African GP

Jackie Stewart at Kyalami, demonstrating both the front and rear wings.

Spanish Grand Prix

Two months later the Spanish Grand Prix of 1969 was held at Montjuich Park which had only been used for a few minor races since the 1930’s.  In 1966 it had been re-opened, resurfaced and had barriers installed and it was now ready to host a Formula One race for the first time.

Lotus were continuing to raise their rear wing ever higher in an effort to get it out of the turbulence created from the chassis, with other teams quickly following suit. This more radical design, associated with its direct connection to the un-sprung wheel assembly, resulted in a structure that was very prone to accidental damage.  Colin Chapman, whose goal was always to have the car as light as possible, wasn’t keen on further reinforcing his wing supports.  Jochen Rindt had already stated his dislike for the high wings and had begun a campaign to try to get them banned.

Unfortunately, Jochen Rindt was about to prove his point in just the way he was trying to avoid.  Graham Hill was on lap 9 of the race and had just crested the rise after the pits when his Lotus became airborne, resulting in a huge negative load on his already fragile rear wing.  His wing folded upwards and then failed dramatically and the car crashed heavily into the barriers.  He was able to emerge from the wreckage unscathed.

11 laps later, while leading the race, Hill’s teammate Jochen Rindt was to suffer an identical failure in exactly the same place. He then proceeded to collide with Hill’s car which had been abandoned by the side of the track, which flipped his own car resulting in it landing upside down. His car was rolled over by the marshals and he was pulled unconscious from his car by Hill (who was watching the race by the side of the track where he had crashed) and was fortunate to have only sustained a broken nose and some minor cuts and bruises (and I’m sure also had a significant concussion which I suspect wasn’t taken seriously by team managers or even doctors at the time).

Jochen Rindt flying at Montjuich Park

Jochen Rindt flying at Montjuich Park

Monaco Grand Prix

After the dramatic crashes at the Spanish Grand Prix the teams were warned before their arrival at Monaco that high wings would be banned for the race.  As well as the crash risk there was concern that the wings would be in danger of colliding with the brick work of buildings overhanging the track and chunks of them flying into the crowd. However, the organisers at Monaco didn’t have the power to ban them and only the Commission Sportive Internationale (CSI) could make that decision. This decision had not yet been officially made.

The Lotus team arrived at Monaco with Graham Hill having to drive the car he had used the previous year due to both the Lotus cars having been totalled during the race in Spain two weeks before. Rindt was not racing because he was still recovering from his injuries (which almost certainly included concussion!). Lotus initially went out for the first practice session on Thursday with their old rear wing that they had used at Monaco the year before but when they noticed that the majority of the field were going out for the first practice with their high wings intact, quickly changed back to their high wing as well.

Rear Wings Banned

Phil Kerr, mechanic to Bruce McLaren, commented that the CSI “held a lengthy meeting after the first session and confirmed the ban on wings but allowed the use of small front aerofoils.  The ruling would also apply to the Dutch Grand Prix and then be reviewed.  This resulted in the teams hurriedly making rear spoilers of varying shapes and sizes for the remainder of practice and the race.”

As was usual, only about half the teams actually attended this meeting and Rob Walker stated that he was informed of the regulation change by a note slipped under his hotel room door.

The only objection to the banning of the high rear aerofoils came from Ken Tyrrell, team principal of Matra, who stated that his car was designed around using wings and it would be very dangerous to drive without them. He accurately stated there was nothing in the regulations against them, but despite vigorous argument with the President of the CSI he was unable to change the decision.  Jack Brabham was also angry as he felt they should have been given more warning about the change.

The limited dimensions decided on for the front wings (they were not allowed to protrude above the bodywork or outside the wheels) resulted in the teams having to get out their files and hacksaws and chop bits off their front wings to suit the new regulations. A commentator at the time said that “Hill’s Lotus, naked without its aerofoils, looked like a page from racing history so familiar had aerofoils become.”

Jackie Stewart’s Matra at Monaco, with front spoilers only

Jackie Stewart’s Matra at Monaco, with front spoilers only

Ferrari and Lotus fitted their curved rear engine covers that they had used the previous year, but Matra would rely on its front wings only.  In the end the cars went as quickly as ever! Jackie Stewart was still the fastest in his Matra and he took his first career pole position beside Chris Amon in his Ferrari.  Graham Hill was back on the second row in fourth. By the end of the race Graham Hill had taken the lead as in front of him Stewart, Beltoise and Amon had all dropped out with mechanical failures, going on to take his fifth victory at Monaco in seven years. It was to be his last Grand Prix win.

Jackie Stewart continued to dominate the rest of the 1969 season, winning 6 races in total, some with huge margins over the rest of the field.  He was the only driver to have won the Driver’s Championship for a French team until Fernando Alonso did so for Renault in 2005.  However, because Alonso’s Renault was built in the United Kingdom, Stewart is still the only driver to win the world championship in a French built car.

Regulations Changed

In the above video of the Monaco Grand Prix the commentator stated that following the race it was announced that high rear aerofoils were banned for the rest of the year.  The only other reliable source I found that talked about the banning of high wings was written by Phil Kerr, Bruce McLaren’s mechanic.  He stated that “The CSI decreed in France that wings would again be permitted but had to comply with regulations covering width and significantly lower height.”

The new regulations stated that:

  1.  The maximum height, width and locations of the wings are controlled
  2. Aerodynamic devices have to be of fixed geometry with no movable parts
  3. They have to be rigidly attached to the body work

The second regulation caused the most difficulty as the engineers now had to compromise between cornering speed and straight line speed. Prior to this many teams had been experimenting with changing the angle of the wing between the corners and the straights.  This regulation would not be altered until the recent advent of DRS.

These new limitations were an attempt to curb the imaginative and often dangerous experimentation of attempting to use the new technology to its best advantage. Because of the changes to rear wing aerodynamics, designers were now faced with trying to work out other ways of increasing the newly discovered gold-mine of downforce to improve grip – something which has remained a pivotal design goal ever since in Formula One.

17 responses to “#F1 History: 1969 – High Wings Banned

  1. Admittedly, I’ve seen the video before. What a crazy weekend. This is one of those clips that reminds you F1 has “always been this way” and in some respects, whether we admit it or not, that’s why we like the sport.

    • Thanks:) This was the hardest one yet to research! So much hearsay and so few primary sources about what actually happened available on the internet. Jennie (taflach)

      • I’d like to second the Judge’s praise. This is a very interesting piece.

        ” so few primary sources about what actually happened available on the internet”

        If I might enquire, where then do you end-up going for the source material? Are there contemporary news reports accessible via any publicly-accessible online news archives?

        Anyway, yeah, great write-up, and thanks for including the video, which I’ve never seen (just learning about the olden days of F1 😉

        • Hi Joe,

          I used the video as it was made shortly after the race and reported on what had been said about the rule changes during and after the race. I couldn’t find any other contemporary reports on-line or any reports/rule changes from the CSI.

          I also used the book “To Finish First” by Phil Kerr, mechanic to Bruce McLaren, which I was lucky enough to get for Christmas:) He has a chapter about the 1969 F1 season and I have put in two quotes from him about what happened at Monaco.

          If anyone else knows of any other sources though I’d love to read them!

          Jennie

        • Excellent article – I remember wondering what was going on at the time as we only had weekly updates from Autosport – pre-internet days!!
          The cars changed seemingly at every race and it was fascinating seeing who would come up with a new solution.

          • It was an amazing time for rapid change in car design. I guess it still happens today but the changes are much less visible now! It’s so amazing how much footage of the races are available to watch – less than 20 years ago we’d only be able to read about it, not actually watch it.

  2. You’re probably right about Rindt having a concussion, given the crash and him being unconsious.
    But is there another reason you highlight this? Like ‘Rindt suffered from headaches after the accident’ or ‘Rindt never got as fast again’ ?

    For the rest, I can only agree with the other compliments!

    • No, only that Rindt wasn’t thought to be significantly injured at the time jbut he still didn’t race at Monaco. I also know that concussion wasn’t taken seriously in sport for a long time and as I am an A&E doctor I was just reading between the lines.:) I probably know a lot more about concussion than F1!

      Jennie:)

      • They seem to go hand in hand…. Perez 2011 Monaco and Kubica Canada 2007 both spring to mind

  3. “This regulation would not be altered until the recent advent of DRS.” Not exactly, you forgot the moveable front wing introduced in 2009.

  4. Pingback: #F1 History: Montjuic – 27th April 1975 | thejudge13·

  5. In the picture of Jackie Stewart at the South African Grand Prix, what is the bit of wire running down from the wing to the engine?

    • There was a short time period when there were no regulations or rules governing wings at all and the driver could alter the angle of his rear wing to decreased drag on the straights so I presume it was something to do with that…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.