The Top-20 #F1 GP Drivers who did NOT win a championship…

Brought to you by TheJudge13 chronicler BlackJack’sBriefs

Such a list is not easy to compile, and it is even harder to be objective.

The way I reduced 830 F1 drivers to 20 is detailed in Part I. I wanted twenty top drivers (top No.2’s who might have been a team leader.) who had proved their ability to win – not drivers who showed talent but were unable to realise their potential, including drivers whose career was brought to an untimely end, for whatever reason.

Didier Pironi17th

Didier Pironi

. . . was born in 1952, in Val-de-Mame, France. After his engineering studies he entered a race-driving school and in 1972 won the Pilot Elf which had also helped Patrick Tambay and Alain Prost. After winning the Formula Renault championship in 1974, and showing considerable talent in Formula Super Renault (12 wins in 16 races) in 1976, Pironi was promoted to F2 for 1977.

This was a time of new French drivers all desperate to be the first French World Champion. The previous year’s F2 champion was Jean-Pierre Jabouille, chased by the Martini duo of Rene Arnoux and Tambay. Tambay had now gone in search of a F1 drive, and Pironi arrived to ‘support’ Arnoux. They were up against Ricardo Patrese, Bruno Giacomelli, Eddie Cheever, Brian Henton, Jacques Lafitte, Alberto Colombo, Ricardo Zunino, Keke Rosberg, Elio de Angelis, a returning Tambay, and Alain Prost… all of whom would reach F1, but only two would take the Champion’s crown.

Pironi’s first few races were dreadful – the Martini wasn’t as fast as the March, and the Renault engine wasn’t as reliable as the Hart – but after a strong second place at Vallelunga, Pironi gambled on a one-off drive in the F3 race at Monaco, where the F1 bosses would be watching… and he so obliterated the opposition he was instantly regarded as a future World Champion.

Throughout the year Pironi usually qualified badly, rarely higher than 10th, but was such a keen racer he often completed the first lap up around 5th. But, in the penultimate round at Estoril Pironi was suddenly on Pole, and he led from start to finish. Arnoux was second, and wrapped up the Championship. In the final race Pironi went from eighth on the grid to third in the race, and third in the Championship. At the end of the year Ken Tyrrell signed Pironi to partner Patrick Depailler in F1 for 1978, probably disappointing a number of his peers who might have expected this glory for themselves.

Subsequently, Pironi was probably also disappointed, with six retirements, and 15th in the Championship, and 1979 was only slightly better – another six retirements but two podiums, to rank 10th in the Championship. However Pironi took an Alpine-Renault to a four-lap victory in the 1978 Le Mans.

For 1980 Pironi was apparently negotiating with Lotus and Brabham but was snatched up by Ligier, to partner Laffite. In the first race Pironi qualified third; in the second he was on the front row, dropped to 21st after a long pitstop, and finished 4th – after which Ferrari started discussions with him for 1981… In his third F1 race Pironi was on the podium, behind Arnoux and Laffite. The French are coming. The French are coming

At Zolder, Pironi’s fifth GP, he started on the front row, this time between Alan Jones and Nelson Piquet, and simply disappeared into the sunset when the flag was waved, taking his first F1 victory – 50 seconds ahead of Jones and nearly 90 ahead of Carlos Reutemann… Didier Pironi had arrived.

Although running third in the Championship at the mid-point a string of four retirements from stunning drives finally dropped him to fifth, two points behind Laffite. Ligier came second in the Constructors Championship.

Ferrari, meanwhile, after eleven retirements, and never finishing higher than fifth, languished down in 10th (just behind McLaren…) – not a good omen for the Part II of Pironi’s career, now partnered with Gilles Villeneuve…

Some have wondered why Pironi left Ligier , which was more successful at the time than Ferrari, but Pironi asserted he had been assured there would be no No.1 driver at Ferrari. Additionally it was not all plain-sailing at Ligier: the cars had suffered numerous mechanical failures and in the British GP, for example, both cars had suffered wheel-rim failures – Laffite had mowed down several safety fences and Pironi had pitted with a flat tyre…

“When I came back to the pits Guy Ligier was telling French journalists that one of his drivers would have won if they had more brains, if they’d drive more cautiously and not go over the kerbs so heavily and treat the car better. At that time I started thinking about my future.”


Enzo Ferrari later recalled, “As soon as Pironi arrived at Maranello, he won everyone’s admiration and affection, not only for his gifts as an athlete, but also for his way of doing things – he was reserved while at the same time outgoing.”

Didier Pironi Ferrari

1981: Villeneuve: 8 retirements, 2 wins, 1 Pole, 1 Fastest lap, 7th in Championship. Pironi: 7 retirements, 1 4th place, 3 5th places, 13th in the Championship. Incidentally, Villeneuve’s younger brother, Jacques Snr, was entered into the final two races in Canada and America by Arrows but he failed to qualify…!

This writer has previously written extensively of the tragic 1982 Season, and of the rivalry between these two great drivers. Villeneuve retired in the first two races, was disqualified from the third, came 2nd to Pironi in the controversial fourth race, and crashed in practice for the fifth… and was killed. Pironi took a second victory, two 2nd places, two 3rd places, and was leading the Championship race… before also crashing (in Germany), and being seriously injured, ending his motor-racing career… He was finally placed 2nd in the Championship, just five points behind Keke Rosberg, having missed the last five events – so close to that elusive title: First French World Champion.

As for San Marino and Zolder, to even suggest Villeneuve’s death two weeks after Pironi’s victory, was somehow Pironi’s fault, is vindictive nonsense. Others have even tried to imply that Pironi’s later accident, which horrifyingly seemed to mirror Villeneuve’s, was some kind of karma

These two men were great racers and, like Senna, Fangio, Vettel, Nuvolari and many others, were not content to sit back if they thought they could pass the driver in front of them. When a driver opts for a safe second place, whether for personal or mechanical reasons, at that moment he ceases to be a racing driver. We admire all these drivers for their ability and willingness to take chances, braking later, passing on the outside of a corner, refusing to give up, and just exciting our senses. “Motor Racing Is Dangerous” We’ve all seen the signs. Pushing a car, and also themselves, beyond the limit causes accidents. It can also have dreadful and tragic consequences.

These are no more the fault of someone else than the fault of the man who stepped on the butterfly…


In his five-year F1 career Didier Pironi had three wins, ten more podium finishes, and four poles. He was a fully committed racer and came so close to his dream as a young man of being France’s first World Champion. Four years, and thirty-nine surgeries, later Pironi tried a comeback. Ligier wanted a replacement for Laffite and apparently McLaren, Brabham and Ferrari all offered him a test-driver role, but Pironi wanted to race, and wanted a car in which he could win.

He tested both an AGS and a Ligier, and his times were considered sufficiently competitive to make a comeback, but… Pironi’s insurance policy had paid out substantial sums of money specifically on the grounds that he was unable to race in F1… Thus a return would have been very costly to him, because he would have had to repay the money. Instead he turned to Power Boat racing and… the following year… was killed in an accident off the Isle of Wight. A few weeks after his death his girlfriend gave birth to twins. She Christened them: Didier and Gilles…

to be continued, next week…


18th – Richie Ginther
19th – Francois Cevert
20th – Peter Collins

17 responses to “The Top-20 #F1 GP Drivers who did NOT win a championship…

  1. “Villeneuve’s father, Jacques Snr, was entered into the final two races”

    Good grief. Jacques Snr, is Gilles Villeneuve’s brother not his father. He’s the uncle of Jacques Villeneuve who drove for Williams, BAR……..

  2. Interesting to see how your top-20 is evolving.

    And we should mention that Pironi wasn’t the only casualty in the fatal powerboat accident: his crewmates died, too! (both of them: Jean-Claude Guenard & Bernard Giroux)

  3. I liked the article. Pironi had the worst ferrari ever (312t5) but, to me, the most beautiful one. And the rivalry between him and villeneuve is certainly open to complot theory’s. As is everything in f1. Many stories about it. Some true others not. But all interesting in their own way. So i enjoyed reading your comments about it but then i got to the “A few weeks after his death his girlfriend gave birth to twins. She Christened them: Didier and Gilles…” part, wich i didn’t knew. And this gave me chills. Talk about a way to start the morning…

    • bruznic, the 312T5 was the 1980 development of the 1979 championship winning 312T4.
      Pironi joined Ferrari for 1981 and the crap they produced was the 126 C, their first turbo car.

  4. Wow BJF, a brave selection and fully deserving of a place in the your Top 20 but I’m not sure I would have placed his name beside the legends you mentioned.
    Imola 1982 is a story unto itself and sometimes the subtleties of the race are missed because of the fatal crash of Villeneuve.
    The Ferrari team orders pre Schumacher days was always the same, when the cars assumed 1-2 position, it was held until the end.
    When Arnoux retired, Villeneuve was the lead driver. He slowed his pace down to 1m38’s when leading due to fuel consumption worries.
    When Pironi passed him, it speeded up to 1m35. Villeneuve assumed they were putting on a show, after all it was depleted field due to the Fisa/ Foca war.
    He re-passed and slowed the pace down to 1-38’s once more.

    It’s one thing feeling hard done by in the Vettel and Webber multi 21 race, quite another when Pironi left it until the last lap to dupe the Canadian.

    Otherwise loving your work, hats off to you.

    • Hello again, Carlo – hope you’re well.
      For every comment I found on the internet similar to yours I found one declaring pretty much the opposite… so I decided to sit on the fence for once… 😉
      Enjoy Christmas…

      • Seasons greetings to you also BJF although with 2 teenage girls and another approaching those years I’d imagine it may not be peace on earth …
        Your piece may well have inspired another article me thinks , but how unbiased I’ll remain I’m not sure as of yet 😉

  5. And the quality keeps coming….


    Btw, THAT battle was my intro to F1. I was 9, and my neighbours Dad got an old film projector of the race, about 6 weeks after it had run.

    I’d never seen a projector before, apart from in the cinema, and I’d never seen an F1 race either as we only had two channels on our TV.

    I was mesmerised. These two beautiful cars bashing off each other, being projected onto a big screen with the speakers turned up loud, Murray Walker in overdrive.

    The race ended and I was totally hooked. My neighbours Dad then told us that the man who came second was killed in a crash. Talk about a shock……

    As intros go, it was pretty spectacular!

    Keep up the excellent work BJF

    • It was actually a very tiny error – and matches the quality of your comments. Get over it… 😉

  6. Another good article, and a really good choice IMO. Didn’t start the last 5 gp’s and still finished only 5 points behind Rosberg. Considering that Pironi managed 5 podiums from his last 6 starts, and that Tambay/Andretti between them only had 1 DNF over those last 5 races, which included a win and a 3rd place, I’m convinced that if not for that accident, Pironi could’ve easily managed to win the title, as the Ferrari had proven to be the most reliable of the turbo cars by mid season.

    Of course that’s still a big “if”, cause we don’t know how things would have changed if Villeneuve had survived too. Still I’ve always thought Pironi was dreadfully underrated, and I think much of that has to do with his feud with Gilles.

    I missed seeing all of it unfortunately, because the first F1 race i saw in full was the 82 German GP. Being a youngster at the time, I wasn’t even aware of who half the drivers were, and I didn’t even know about Pironi’s accident earlier, nor of the other tragedies earlier in the year.

    My most vivid recollection of that race was the well-known incident with Piquet and Salazer, and it wasn’t until a month or so later that I picked up one of my fathers motoring magazines to read a review of the race where I then learned about what what happened to Pironi.

    I can still recall a picture from the article, taken in black and white, of Pironi lying in his wrecked car, conscious, helmet off but balaclava still on, looking up at those standing round him, the dark eye openings in the white balaclava combined with the picture being in b&w making him seem ghostly, almost inhuman.. as a ten year-old at the time it was a rather disturbing image, particularly when reading the accompanying text, in particular Prosts recollection when he went over and saw “bones sticking out”.

    • Thanks for the comments – it’s always those first memories that stay in the mind, whatever else happens. Maybe some of you should develop those impressions into full articles for the ‘off-season’…

  7. Pingback: The Top-20 #F1 GP Drivers who did NOT win a championship… | thejudge13·

  8. Pingback: The Top-20 #F1 GP Drivers who did NOT win a championship… | thejudge13·

  9. Pingback: The Top-20 #F1 GP Drivers who did NOT win a championship… | thejudge13·

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.